Determinism Doctrine

  • Uncategorized

DETERMINISM DOCTRINE 5

DeterminismDoctrine

Accordingto the principle of determinism, events that happen in our dailylives are pre-determined. The doctrine argues that humans can settheir future goals and path of success. Nonetheless, the principlefails to consider other contributing factors that influence anindividual’s future. It is not possible to predetermine the futureevents or occurrences as it takes natural and physical influences.Most of the actions or events that place in the physical worldthroughout our lives emanate from necessity or inevitability. As thewriter observes, it is true that some actions in our societyoriginate from people’s choices. The tendency of owning up willcome in the form of adherence to policies, legislations, and engagingin the right things. The essence of free will is where humans havethe capacity to make smart and intelligent choices. Such a move isessential to the accomplishment of one’s future goals.

Humans’inward feelings or thoughts ought to reflect our hunger for takingresponsibility for our deeds. It is true that determinism is acomplicated concept in philosophy. The society needs to setguidelines and regulations or standards that should be followed byeveryone. Through such an approach, we will be in a better positionto hold individuals accountable for their deeds. Human life has amyriad of influences and factors that control the realization ofambitions or even the occurrence of events. Determinism doctrine doesnot offer an accurate reflection of humans’ life path.

Response1

Iagree with the student that individuals have no free will orresponsibility for most of their actions as explained through thedeterminism philosophical principle. The thinking is that peopleought to be held responsible for their actions, whether good or bad.Whereas humans do not contribute all the actions, it is evident thatsome activities contribute to particular consequences in the society.As the author correctly observes, people need to own to their actionsbesides engaging in proper deeds to prevent the occurrence ofproblems that affect the society. Failure to own up will contributefree society that has no rules, where everyone acts according to whatpleases him or her.

Ialso agree that humans remain determined to stand by their belief,hence, making it difficult to alter their reasoning. The writercorrectly highlights the possibility of holding people accountablefor their deeds in a deterministic society. I agree that we requirestandards to inform our goals and behaviors. I also concur with thewriter on the importance of starting the virtue of accountabilitywithin self (Berofsky,2015).

Response2

Asthe writer notes from the beginning of the essay, determinism is acomplicated philosophical concept that limits possibilities. It istrue from the essay that humans cannot plan for the course of thefuture events. In one way or another, there exists multipleinfluences such as natural factors that control the attainment of ourplanned goals. I concur with the writer that determinism is notentirely true, as people cannot change their destiny as they wish. Asthe discussion portrays, it is true that determinism would limit thechoices of people on several issues. As noted, people fail to engagein certain deeds or behaviors since they do not attend to their needsor have adverse impacts.

Itis also true that people are driven by desires and dispositions thatmay never come to fruition. I am in agreement with the writer thatthe deterministic view is not in any way true or practical. Besides,I concur that experiences play a crucial role in affecting ourchoices and actions since we already know the consequences. Each day,humans make decisions that have either positive or negative effectstowards their lives. Unfortunately, we do not always have controlover the consequences, therefore, rendering the concept ofdeterminism undependable (Berofsky,2015).

Reference

Berofsky,B. (2015). Determinism.Princeton, New Jersey: Princeton University Press.

Close Menu